Odd Harmonics in Exoplanet Photometry: Weather or Artifact?

In the Fourier decomposition of light curves of exoplanets observed by the Kepler mission, one expects to see power in the first mode, from the planet orbiting the star, and the second mode, from ellipsoidal variations. Observations of power in the third mode of planets such as HAT-P-7b and Kepler-13Ab are as of yet unexplained. Using a spherical harmonic basis we analyze planet maps to find their corresponding light curves and show that no planet observed edge-on can produce these third harmonics with either reflected light or thermal emissions. Further numerical and analytic calculations put upper bounds on the power in the third mode that can be produced by planets not transiting perfectly edge-on, or with time-variable maps. We find the expected order of magnitude of these contributions to be at most two orders of magnitude below the first harmonic. The North-South asymmetric features or time-variable maps that could produce such harmonics would suggest exoplanetary weather if observed. However, more careful analysis of tidal effects on the stars of HAT-P-7b and Kepler-13Ab suggest that these particular harmonics are stellar in origin.