Quantum theory cannot be extended

ORAL

Abstract

Predictions made by quantum theory are generally not deterministic: the theory tells us only how to calculate the probabilities with which measurement outcomes occur. This indeterminism is one of the key differences from classical mechanics and one can ask whether this is the best any theory can offer, or whether observable quantities could be better predicted by some higher theory. In a famous work, Bell considered extensions of quantum theory in the form of local hidden variables and showed that these cannot determine the outcomes of measurements on maximally entangled particles. Here, we go beyond the case of such classical extensions and ask whether any improved predictions can be achieved by any extension of quantum theory. We answer this question in the negative. More precisely, under the assumption that measurement settings can be chosen freely, there cannot exist any extension of quantum theory that provides us with any additional information about the outcomes of future measurements.

Authors

  • Roger Colbeck

    Perimeter Institute, Canada

  • Renato Renner

    ETH Zurich, ETH Zurich, Switzerland