Intrinsic versus extrinsic cellular decision making

A cell routinely responds to one of many competing environmental cues. Does the cell have an intrinsic preference for that cue, or does that cue have the highest extrinsic information content? We introduce a theoretical framework to answer this fundamental question. We derive extrinsic detection limits for four types of directional cues—external and self-generated chemical gradients, fluid flow, and contact inhibition of locomotion—and thus predict extrinsic decision boundaries when these cues compete as pairs. Comparing the boundaries to published data from cell migration experiments quantitatively determines the degree to which cell decisions are intrinsic vs. extrinsic, revealing the extent of cells' autonomy and providing interpretation of their response networks.